When it comes to crowning the greatest lacrosse players of all time, the conversation is bound to get heated. From field to box, midfielders to goalies, the sport has seen generational talents who’ve redefined the game. At Lacrosse Unlimited, we’re diving into the elite, the absolute legends whose legacy goes beyond stats and into the soul of the sport.
Gary Gait (Field & Box)
No list is complete without the Air Gait. From his Syracuse dominance to revolutionizing the sport with his signature style, Gary Gait changed the way lacrosse is played. He’s a multi-time MVP in both the NLL and international competition, and is now influencing the game from the sidelines as a coach.
John Tavares (Box)
The all-time leader in NLL points, assists, and goals, John Tavares is simply iconic. Known for his IQ, vision, and consistency, he played over 300 games in the National Lacrosse League and was a dominant force until the very end. His impact on box lacrosse is unmatched — and yes, he’s also the uncle of NHL star John Tavares.
John Grant Jr. (Box and Field)
Highlight reels were made for guys like Grant Jr. His left-handed scoring, jaw-dropping fakes, and pinpoint vision made him a nightmare for defenders. He’s top 2 in all-time NLL points and brought creativity and flair to the highest level.
Casey Powell (Field)
One of the most versatile American lacrosse players ever, Powell starred at Syracuse before dominating in the pros. He was the first American to win NLL MVP and remains a powerful ambassador for the game worldwide.
Tom Schreiber (Field & Box)
The modern-day midfield maestro, Schreiber has elevated the position with his vision, shooting, and field awareness. He’s a multi-time PLL MVP and has seamlessly adapted to box lacrosse, proving he's not just great — he’s generational.
Jim Brown (Field)
Yes, that Jim Brown. Before becoming an NFL legend, Brown was a multi-sport athlete at Syracuse and arguably the most dominant lacrosse player of his era. Fast, physical, and unstoppable, many old-school fans still call him the greatest to ever pick up a stick.
Brian Dougherty (Goalie)
The wall in the net. Dougherty was known for his clutch performances and acrobatic saves. He helped elevate the goalie position with quick hands, elite communication, and fearless leadership — a true Hall of Famer.
Brodie Merrill (Defense)
One of the best long-stick midfielders and defenders of all time. Merrill’s ground ball stats are off the charts, and his ability to transition from defense to offense is what made him a difference-maker in every game he played.
Colin Doyle (Box)
Captain Clutch. Doyle was the definition of consistency and leadership. He brought championships to Toronto and delivered in the biggest moments time and time again. One of the most respected names in NLL history.
Jim Veltman (Box)
Known as “Scoop” for his ridiculous ability to pick up loose balls, Veltman was the heartbeat of any team he played on. His leadership, hustle, and ability to control the pace of the game made him a true legend in the box game.
Honorable Mentions:
Matt Vinc – One of the winningest goalies in NLL history.
Paul Gait – Gary’s twin and just as dangerous on the field.
Sal LoCascio – Set the standard for U.S. goalies in the indoor game.
Tom Marechek – Syracuse sniper with an electric scoring touch.
Greatness in lacrosse can’t be measured by stats alone. It’s about how you influence the game, inspire the next generation, and leave your mark on the culture. These 10 players (plus a few extra) did just that. Whether you’re a fan of finesse, grit, or game-breaking plays, this list has someone who left it all on the field (or the turf).
Who’s on your GOAT list? Let us know on Instagram or stop by one of our stores to debate with the staff.